Judgement Prior To 31.05.2021

Judgement
Sr. No. Company Appeal (AT) No Date of order Party Section Court Name Order Passed By View/Download Remarks
241 437/2020 17/02/2021 Hem Chander Vs Ganesh Prasad Agarwal & Ors. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1147816640602f5ba1d334f.pdf NULL
242 96/2021 16/02/2021 Jalesh Kumar Grover Vs Committee of Creditors of Akme Projects Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/908379882602baf9297b79.pdf NULL
243 280/2020 16/02/2021 Biswanath Paul Vs Santosh Devi @ Tibrewala & Anr. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1873372003602caba7cf4dd.pdf NULL
244 93/2021 16/02/2021 Surendra Singh Hada & Ors Vs Arfat Petrochemicals Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1947986100602bafb6cfc58.pdf NULL
245 99/2021 16/02/2021 Power Finance Corporation Ltd Vs Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1901544131602baf364911d.pdf NULL
246 100/2021 16/02/2021 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd Vs Indian Speciality Fats Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1990523822602baf170a8d7.pdf NULL
247 97/2021 16/02/2021 JJE Adornment Pvt Ltd Vs Pingle Builders Pvt Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1004278660602baf6318a01.pdf NULL
248 94/2020 15/02/2021 Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/444534981602a1abfe54c2.pdf
249 110/2021 15/02/2021 IIFL Finance Ltd Formerly India Infoline Finance Ltd Vs AVJ Developers India Pvt Ltd and Anr through RP Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/2118288792602a4ee56ea83.pdf NULL
250 116/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/279203535602a6770d3f4d.pdf NULL
251 95/2020 15/02/2021 Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd Vs Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/435878437602a1a9a5667f.pdf NULL
252 632/2020 15/02/2021 Aparna Enterprise Ltd Vs SJR Prime Corporation Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/529496215602a23358bc28.pdf NULL
253 115/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1252667763602a67581637b.pdf NULL
254 114/2021 15/02/2021 Sudhir Agarwal Vs CHD Developers Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/260903173602a67c7e34e6.pdf NULL
255 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/699262979602e20d3cdc66.pdf NULL
256 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1541882961602fa0e331699.pdf Corrected
257 134/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Anr Vs Soham Renewable Energy India Pvt Ltd & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/181362881460264e8730b2a.pdf NULL
258 92/2021 12/02/2021 Krishna Garg & Anr Vs Pioneer Fabricators Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/162148582560265274c5009.pdf NULL
259 903/2020 12/02/2021 Victor Vanya Bandlamudi Vs Mercados Energy Markets India Pvt Ltd Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/862651490602a79456e05b.pdf NULL
260 511/2020 12/02/2021 RK Associates & Hoteliers Pvt Ltd Vs BW Businessworld Media Pvt Ltd Through its Managing Director Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/24713825060264e6ab89bd.pdf NULL
261 135/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Ors Vs K Sadananda Shetty & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/68303500260264e9ef1fd8.pdf NULL
262 Feb-21 12/02/2021 Devas Employees Mauritius Pvt Ltd Vs Antrix Corporation Ltd & Ors Company Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/20992109036026166163c13.pdf NULL
263 81/2021 11/02/2021 Manoj Chaudhary Vs Sarvesh Kashyap Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/92433177960251d2770303.pdf NULL
264 Mar-21 11/02/2021 Ashish Arjunkumar Rath Vs Power Finance Corporation Ltd & Ors Insolvency Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/640223714602523ee9f290.pdf NULL
265 334/2020 11/02/2021 Suri Rajendra Rolling Mills Vs Bengani Udyog Private Limited Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1878525425602519062fe11.pdf NULL
266 82/2021 11/02/2021 Kamal Uttamchand Jain & Anr Erstwhile Directors of Goodwill Theaters Pvt Ltd Vs Sunteck Realty Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/95239652960251d45a54ea.pdf NULL
267 87/2021 10/02/2021 Moser Baer Karamchari Union Gautam Buddh Nagar Vs Mr Anil Kohli Liquidator for Moser Baer India Ltd & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/510191799602cb842b28e4.pdf NULL
268 1415/2019 09/02/2021 Narayan Singh Pathania Vs Valuelabs LLP Insolvency Court - 3 Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical) Download upload/868446069602248a507682.pdf NULL
269 73/2021 09/02/2021 Vivek Raheja Vs Vijay Purohit & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/9074871066023a9309b102.pdf NULL
270 624/2020 08/02/2021 Om Prakash Agrawal LiquidatorS Kumars Nationwide Ltd Vs Chief Commissioner of Income Tax TDS & Anr Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/155180032160212e9286f98.pdf NULL
Judgement
Sr. No. Company Appeal (AT) No Date of order Party Section Court Name Order Passed By View/Download Remarks
241 437/2020 17/02/2021 Hem Chander Vs Ganesh Prasad Agarwal & Ors. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1147816640602f5ba1d334f.pdf NULL
242 96/2021 16/02/2021 Jalesh Kumar Grover Vs Committee of Creditors of Akme Projects Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/908379882602baf9297b79.pdf NULL
243 280/2020 16/02/2021 Biswanath Paul Vs Santosh Devi @ Tibrewala & Anr. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1873372003602caba7cf4dd.pdf NULL
244 93/2021 16/02/2021 Surendra Singh Hada & Ors Vs Arfat Petrochemicals Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1947986100602bafb6cfc58.pdf NULL
245 99/2021 16/02/2021 Power Finance Corporation Ltd Vs Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1901544131602baf364911d.pdf NULL
246 100/2021 16/02/2021 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd Vs Indian Speciality Fats Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1990523822602baf170a8d7.pdf NULL
247 97/2021 16/02/2021 JJE Adornment Pvt Ltd Vs Pingle Builders Pvt Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1004278660602baf6318a01.pdf NULL
248 94/2020 15/02/2021 Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/444534981602a1abfe54c2.pdf
249 110/2021 15/02/2021 IIFL Finance Ltd Formerly India Infoline Finance Ltd Vs AVJ Developers India Pvt Ltd and Anr through RP Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/2118288792602a4ee56ea83.pdf NULL
250 116/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/279203535602a6770d3f4d.pdf NULL
251 95/2020 15/02/2021 Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd Vs Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/435878437602a1a9a5667f.pdf NULL
252 632/2020 15/02/2021 Aparna Enterprise Ltd Vs SJR Prime Corporation Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/529496215602a23358bc28.pdf NULL
253 115/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1252667763602a67581637b.pdf NULL
254 114/2021 15/02/2021 Sudhir Agarwal Vs CHD Developers Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/260903173602a67c7e34e6.pdf NULL
255 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/699262979602e20d3cdc66.pdf NULL
256 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1541882961602fa0e331699.pdf Corrected
257 134/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Anr Vs Soham Renewable Energy India Pvt Ltd & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/181362881460264e8730b2a.pdf NULL
258 92/2021 12/02/2021 Krishna Garg & Anr Vs Pioneer Fabricators Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/162148582560265274c5009.pdf NULL
259 903/2020 12/02/2021 Victor Vanya Bandlamudi Vs Mercados Energy Markets India Pvt Ltd Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/862651490602a79456e05b.pdf NULL
260 511/2020 12/02/2021 RK Associates & Hoteliers Pvt Ltd Vs BW Businessworld Media Pvt Ltd Through its Managing Director Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/24713825060264e6ab89bd.pdf NULL
261 135/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Ors Vs K Sadananda Shetty & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/68303500260264e9ef1fd8.pdf NULL
262 Feb-21 12/02/2021 Devas Employees Mauritius Pvt Ltd Vs Antrix Corporation Ltd & Ors Company Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/20992109036026166163c13.pdf NULL
263 81/2021 11/02/2021 Manoj Chaudhary Vs Sarvesh Kashyap Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/92433177960251d2770303.pdf NULL
264 Mar-21 11/02/2021 Ashish Arjunkumar Rath Vs Power Finance Corporation Ltd & Ors Insolvency Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/640223714602523ee9f290.pdf NULL
265 334/2020 11/02/2021 Suri Rajendra Rolling Mills Vs Bengani Udyog Private Limited Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1878525425602519062fe11.pdf NULL
266 82/2021 11/02/2021 Kamal Uttamchand Jain & Anr Erstwhile Directors of Goodwill Theaters Pvt Ltd Vs Sunteck Realty Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/95239652960251d45a54ea.pdf NULL
267 87/2021 10/02/2021 Moser Baer Karamchari Union Gautam Buddh Nagar Vs Mr Anil Kohli Liquidator for Moser Baer India Ltd & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/510191799602cb842b28e4.pdf NULL
268 1415/2019 09/02/2021 Narayan Singh Pathania Vs Valuelabs LLP Insolvency Court - 3 Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical) Download upload/868446069602248a507682.pdf NULL
269 73/2021 09/02/2021 Vivek Raheja Vs Vijay Purohit & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/9074871066023a9309b102.pdf NULL
270 624/2020 08/02/2021 Om Prakash Agrawal LiquidatorS Kumars Nationwide Ltd Vs Chief Commissioner of Income Tax TDS & Anr Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/155180032160212e9286f98.pdf NULL
Judgement
Sr. No. Company Appeal (AT) No Date of order Party Section Court Name Order Passed By View/Download Remarks
241 437/2020 17/02/2021 Hem Chander Vs Ganesh Prasad Agarwal & Ors. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1147816640602f5ba1d334f.pdf NULL
242 96/2021 16/02/2021 Jalesh Kumar Grover Vs Committee of Creditors of Akme Projects Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/908379882602baf9297b79.pdf NULL
243 280/2020 16/02/2021 Biswanath Paul Vs Santosh Devi @ Tibrewala & Anr. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1873372003602caba7cf4dd.pdf NULL
244 93/2021 16/02/2021 Surendra Singh Hada & Ors Vs Arfat Petrochemicals Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1947986100602bafb6cfc58.pdf NULL
245 99/2021 16/02/2021 Power Finance Corporation Ltd Vs Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1901544131602baf364911d.pdf NULL
246 100/2021 16/02/2021 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd Vs Indian Speciality Fats Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1990523822602baf170a8d7.pdf NULL
247 97/2021 16/02/2021 JJE Adornment Pvt Ltd Vs Pingle Builders Pvt Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1004278660602baf6318a01.pdf NULL
248 94/2020 15/02/2021 Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/444534981602a1abfe54c2.pdf
249 110/2021 15/02/2021 IIFL Finance Ltd Formerly India Infoline Finance Ltd Vs AVJ Developers India Pvt Ltd and Anr through RP Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/2118288792602a4ee56ea83.pdf NULL
250 116/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/279203535602a6770d3f4d.pdf NULL
251 95/2020 15/02/2021 Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd Vs Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/435878437602a1a9a5667f.pdf NULL
252 632/2020 15/02/2021 Aparna Enterprise Ltd Vs SJR Prime Corporation Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/529496215602a23358bc28.pdf NULL
253 115/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1252667763602a67581637b.pdf NULL
254 114/2021 15/02/2021 Sudhir Agarwal Vs CHD Developers Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/260903173602a67c7e34e6.pdf NULL
255 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/699262979602e20d3cdc66.pdf NULL
256 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1541882961602fa0e331699.pdf Corrected
257 134/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Anr Vs Soham Renewable Energy India Pvt Ltd & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/181362881460264e8730b2a.pdf NULL
258 92/2021 12/02/2021 Krishna Garg & Anr Vs Pioneer Fabricators Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/162148582560265274c5009.pdf NULL
259 903/2020 12/02/2021 Victor Vanya Bandlamudi Vs Mercados Energy Markets India Pvt Ltd Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/862651490602a79456e05b.pdf NULL
260 511/2020 12/02/2021 RK Associates & Hoteliers Pvt Ltd Vs BW Businessworld Media Pvt Ltd Through its Managing Director Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/24713825060264e6ab89bd.pdf NULL
261 135/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Ors Vs K Sadananda Shetty & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/68303500260264e9ef1fd8.pdf NULL
262 Feb-21 12/02/2021 Devas Employees Mauritius Pvt Ltd Vs Antrix Corporation Ltd & Ors Company Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/20992109036026166163c13.pdf NULL
263 81/2021 11/02/2021 Manoj Chaudhary Vs Sarvesh Kashyap Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/92433177960251d2770303.pdf NULL
264 Mar-21 11/02/2021 Ashish Arjunkumar Rath Vs Power Finance Corporation Ltd & Ors Insolvency Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/640223714602523ee9f290.pdf NULL
265 334/2020 11/02/2021 Suri Rajendra Rolling Mills Vs Bengani Udyog Private Limited Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1878525425602519062fe11.pdf NULL
266 82/2021 11/02/2021 Kamal Uttamchand Jain & Anr Erstwhile Directors of Goodwill Theaters Pvt Ltd Vs Sunteck Realty Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/95239652960251d45a54ea.pdf NULL
267 87/2021 10/02/2021 Moser Baer Karamchari Union Gautam Buddh Nagar Vs Mr Anil Kohli Liquidator for Moser Baer India Ltd & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/510191799602cb842b28e4.pdf NULL
268 1415/2019 09/02/2021 Narayan Singh Pathania Vs Valuelabs LLP Insolvency Court - 3 Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical) Download upload/868446069602248a507682.pdf NULL
269 73/2021 09/02/2021 Vivek Raheja Vs Vijay Purohit & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/9074871066023a9309b102.pdf NULL
270 624/2020 08/02/2021 Om Prakash Agrawal LiquidatorS Kumars Nationwide Ltd Vs Chief Commissioner of Income Tax TDS & Anr Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/155180032160212e9286f98.pdf NULL
Judgement
Sr. No. Company Appeal (AT) No Date of order Party Section Court Name Order Passed By View/Download Remarks
241 437/2020 17/02/2021 Hem Chander Vs Ganesh Prasad Agarwal & Ors. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1147816640602f5ba1d334f.pdf NULL
242 96/2021 16/02/2021 Jalesh Kumar Grover Vs Committee of Creditors of Akme Projects Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/908379882602baf9297b79.pdf NULL
243 280/2020 16/02/2021 Biswanath Paul Vs Santosh Devi @ Tibrewala & Anr. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1873372003602caba7cf4dd.pdf NULL
244 93/2021 16/02/2021 Surendra Singh Hada & Ors Vs Arfat Petrochemicals Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1947986100602bafb6cfc58.pdf NULL
245 99/2021 16/02/2021 Power Finance Corporation Ltd Vs Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1901544131602baf364911d.pdf NULL
246 100/2021 16/02/2021 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd Vs Indian Speciality Fats Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1990523822602baf170a8d7.pdf NULL
247 97/2021 16/02/2021 JJE Adornment Pvt Ltd Vs Pingle Builders Pvt Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1004278660602baf6318a01.pdf NULL
248 94/2020 15/02/2021 Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/444534981602a1abfe54c2.pdf
249 110/2021 15/02/2021 IIFL Finance Ltd Formerly India Infoline Finance Ltd Vs AVJ Developers India Pvt Ltd and Anr through RP Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/2118288792602a4ee56ea83.pdf NULL
250 116/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/279203535602a6770d3f4d.pdf NULL
251 95/2020 15/02/2021 Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd Vs Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/435878437602a1a9a5667f.pdf NULL
252 632/2020 15/02/2021 Aparna Enterprise Ltd Vs SJR Prime Corporation Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/529496215602a23358bc28.pdf NULL
253 115/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1252667763602a67581637b.pdf NULL
254 114/2021 15/02/2021 Sudhir Agarwal Vs CHD Developers Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/260903173602a67c7e34e6.pdf NULL
255 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/699262979602e20d3cdc66.pdf NULL
256 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1541882961602fa0e331699.pdf Corrected
257 134/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Anr Vs Soham Renewable Energy India Pvt Ltd & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/181362881460264e8730b2a.pdf NULL
258 92/2021 12/02/2021 Krishna Garg & Anr Vs Pioneer Fabricators Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/162148582560265274c5009.pdf NULL
259 903/2020 12/02/2021 Victor Vanya Bandlamudi Vs Mercados Energy Markets India Pvt Ltd Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/862651490602a79456e05b.pdf NULL
260 511/2020 12/02/2021 RK Associates & Hoteliers Pvt Ltd Vs BW Businessworld Media Pvt Ltd Through its Managing Director Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/24713825060264e6ab89bd.pdf NULL
261 135/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Ors Vs K Sadananda Shetty & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/68303500260264e9ef1fd8.pdf NULL
262 Feb-21 12/02/2021 Devas Employees Mauritius Pvt Ltd Vs Antrix Corporation Ltd & Ors Company Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/20992109036026166163c13.pdf NULL
263 81/2021 11/02/2021 Manoj Chaudhary Vs Sarvesh Kashyap Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/92433177960251d2770303.pdf NULL
264 Mar-21 11/02/2021 Ashish Arjunkumar Rath Vs Power Finance Corporation Ltd & Ors Insolvency Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/640223714602523ee9f290.pdf NULL
265 334/2020 11/02/2021 Suri Rajendra Rolling Mills Vs Bengani Udyog Private Limited Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1878525425602519062fe11.pdf NULL
266 82/2021 11/02/2021 Kamal Uttamchand Jain & Anr Erstwhile Directors of Goodwill Theaters Pvt Ltd Vs Sunteck Realty Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/95239652960251d45a54ea.pdf NULL
267 87/2021 10/02/2021 Moser Baer Karamchari Union Gautam Buddh Nagar Vs Mr Anil Kohli Liquidator for Moser Baer India Ltd & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/510191799602cb842b28e4.pdf NULL
268 1415/2019 09/02/2021 Narayan Singh Pathania Vs Valuelabs LLP Insolvency Court - 3 Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical) Download upload/868446069602248a507682.pdf NULL
269 73/2021 09/02/2021 Vivek Raheja Vs Vijay Purohit & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/9074871066023a9309b102.pdf NULL
270 624/2020 08/02/2021 Om Prakash Agrawal LiquidatorS Kumars Nationwide Ltd Vs Chief Commissioner of Income Tax TDS & Anr Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/155180032160212e9286f98.pdf NULL
Judgement
Sr. No. Company Appeal (AT) No Date of order Party Section Court Name Order Passed By View/Download Remarks
241 437/2020 17/02/2021 Hem Chander Vs Ganesh Prasad Agarwal & Ors. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1147816640602f5ba1d334f.pdf NULL
242 96/2021 16/02/2021 Jalesh Kumar Grover Vs Committee of Creditors of Akme Projects Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/908379882602baf9297b79.pdf NULL
243 280/2020 16/02/2021 Biswanath Paul Vs Santosh Devi @ Tibrewala & Anr. Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/1873372003602caba7cf4dd.pdf NULL
244 93/2021 16/02/2021 Surendra Singh Hada & Ors Vs Arfat Petrochemicals Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1947986100602bafb6cfc58.pdf NULL
245 99/2021 16/02/2021 Power Finance Corporation Ltd Vs Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1901544131602baf364911d.pdf NULL
246 100/2021 16/02/2021 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd Vs Indian Speciality Fats Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1990523822602baf170a8d7.pdf NULL
247 97/2021 16/02/2021 JJE Adornment Pvt Ltd Vs Pingle Builders Pvt Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1004278660602baf6318a01.pdf NULL
248 94/2020 15/02/2021 Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/444534981602a1abfe54c2.pdf
249 110/2021 15/02/2021 IIFL Finance Ltd Formerly India Infoline Finance Ltd Vs AVJ Developers India Pvt Ltd and Anr through RP Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/2118288792602a4ee56ea83.pdf NULL
250 116/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/279203535602a6770d3f4d.pdf NULL
251 95/2020 15/02/2021 Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd Vs Union of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs & Ors Company Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/435878437602a1a9a5667f.pdf NULL
252 632/2020 15/02/2021 Aparna Enterprise Ltd Vs SJR Prime Corporation Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Justice Anant Bijay Singh, Member(Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/529496215602a23358bc28.pdf NULL
253 115/2021 15/02/2021 Committee of Creditors Through Shri Ashish Kumar Srivastava Vs Sanjay Gupta and Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/1252667763602a67581637b.pdf NULL
254 114/2021 15/02/2021 Sudhir Agarwal Vs CHD Developers Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/260903173602a67c7e34e6.pdf NULL
255 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/699262979602e20d3cdc66.pdf NULL
256 971/2020 12/02/2021 Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd Vs Bhuvnesh Maheshwari m & Ors Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1541882961602fa0e331699.pdf Corrected
257 134/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Anr Vs Soham Renewable Energy India Pvt Ltd & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/181362881460264e8730b2a.pdf NULL
258 92/2021 12/02/2021 Krishna Garg & Anr Vs Pioneer Fabricators Pvt Ltd Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/162148582560265274c5009.pdf NULL
259 903/2020 12/02/2021 Victor Vanya Bandlamudi Vs Mercados Energy Markets India Pvt Ltd Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/862651490602a79456e05b.pdf NULL
260 511/2020 12/02/2021 RK Associates & Hoteliers Pvt Ltd Vs BW Businessworld Media Pvt Ltd Through its Managing Director Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/24713825060264e6ab89bd.pdf NULL
261 135/2020 12/02/2021 Macquarie SBI Infrastructure Investments Pte Ltd & Ors Vs K Sadananda Shetty & Ors Company Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Mr. Kanthi Narahari Member (Technical) Download upload/68303500260264e9ef1fd8.pdf NULL
262 Feb-21 12/02/2021 Devas Employees Mauritius Pvt Ltd Vs Antrix Corporation Ltd & Ors Company Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/20992109036026166163c13.pdf NULL
263 81/2021 11/02/2021 Manoj Chaudhary Vs Sarvesh Kashyap Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/92433177960251d2770303.pdf NULL
264 Mar-21 11/02/2021 Ashish Arjunkumar Rath Vs Power Finance Corporation Ltd & Ors Insolvency Chennai Bench Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Mr. Balvinder Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/640223714602523ee9f290.pdf NULL
265 334/2020 11/02/2021 Suri Rajendra Rolling Mills Vs Bengani Udyog Private Limited Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/1878525425602519062fe11.pdf NULL
266 82/2021 11/02/2021 Kamal Uttamchand Jain & Anr Erstwhile Directors of Goodwill Theaters Pvt Ltd Vs Sunteck Realty Ltd & Anr Insolvency Chairperson Court Justice Bansi Lal Bhat Acting Chairperson, Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical), Dr. Alok Srivastava, Member (Technical) Download upload/95239652960251d45a54ea.pdf NULL
267 87/2021 10/02/2021 Moser Baer Karamchari Union Gautam Buddh Nagar Vs Mr Anil Kohli Liquidator for Moser Baer India Ltd & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/510191799602cb842b28e4.pdf NULL
268 1415/2019 09/02/2021 Narayan Singh Pathania Vs Valuelabs LLP Insolvency Court - 3 Justice Venugopal M Member (Judicial), Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical) Download upload/868446069602248a507682.pdf NULL
269 73/2021 09/02/2021 Vivek Raheja Vs Vijay Purohit & Anr Insolvency Court - 2 Justice A.I.S. Cheema Member (Judicial), Mr. V. P. Singh Member (Technical) Download upload/9074871066023a9309b102.pdf NULL
270 624/2020 08/02/2021 Om Prakash Agrawal LiquidatorS Kumars Nationwide Ltd Vs Chief Commissioner of Income Tax TDS & Anr Insolvency Court - 4 Justice Jarat Kumar Jain Member (Judicial), Dr. Ashok Kumar Mishra Member (Technical) Download upload/155180032160212e9286f98.pdf NULL